ALTERCATIONES

ALTERCATIONES. By altercatio, Latin rhetoric means a debate in which the pro and the contra are set in opposition see Quint., Inst. or. VI,4. Originally a part of discourse, the altercatio came to be used also for didactic and exegetical purposes. In the ancient Christian literature of the West the concept is used primarily for an imaginary debate in which a Christian disputes with a Jew, but also an orthodox with a heretic or a Christian with a pagan. Thus Jerome defines the dialogue mentioned by Origen in Cels. IV, 52 between Papiscus and Jason as an altercatio Com. Gal. 3,13 cf. Tertull., Adv. Prax. 22; Adv. Marc. 1,9. An early 5th-c. work titled Altercatio Ecclesiae et Synagogae CPL 577 is attributed to Augustine or Vigilius. From the same period, according to Gennadius Vir. ill. 50, is the Altercatio Simonis et Theophili, composed by the Gallic monk Evagrius see Sulp. Sev., Dial. 3,1, the last early Christian controversy against the Jews CPL 482. In it, following the model of Tertullian, Cyprian, Gregory of Elvira and others, the divinity of the crucified one is demonstrated exclusively from the OT. From the Arian controversy we have the Altercatio Heracliani laici cum Germinio episcopo CPL 687, in which Nicene faith and the confession of Rimini are opposed see B. Windau, in LACL 287, bibl.. From the 6th c. are the Altercationes of Christian philosophy against pagan errors, compiled in Italy or Africa based on texts of Augustine CPL 360. For a literary judgment on these or other Altercationes, one must bear in mind the various ancient forms of dialogue, whereas for their theological evaluation one must bear in mind the anti-Jewish and antiheretical traditions.

Maybe You Like Them Too

Leave a Reply

+ 9 = 16